A dock on the Sugar Camp Chain near Eagle River, Wisconsin, as the lake begins to freeze
← The Journal

Northwoods Journal · Winter

Reading first ice

How early ice comes in on the Eagle River Chain, where it stays thin, and how we decide whether to step out on it.

There is a stretch of the Northwoods calendar that locals quietly love and visitors almost never see: the few weeks when the lakes stop moving. The docks come out, the shoreline goes quiet, and one morning the bays around the cabins are skinned over. First ice is the best fishing of the winter and the most dangerous. Here is how we think about it on the Eagle River Chain and the Sugar Camp Chain.

Timing

How does first ice come in up here?

Ice does not arrive all at once. The shallow, sheltered water goes first — back bays, narrows, the shoreline in front of a dock — because there is less water to cool and less wind to stir it. The big open basins can stay black and rolling for weeks after the bays have locked up. A hard, still, clear cold snap builds ice fast; wind and a warm afternoon undo a surprising amount of it.

That means two things in practice. First, there is usually fishable ice somewhere before there is fishable ice everywhere, which is exactly why early-ice anglers do so well. Second, the words “the lake froze” are never true about a whole chain at the same time. If you want the longer version of how freeze-up unfolds here, we wrote it up in our guide to ice-up on the chain.

Thickness

How much ice is enough?

The numbers below are the general guidelines anglers in this part of Wisconsin go by, and they assume new, clear, solid ice. Cloudy white ice, refrozen slush and honeycombed late-season ice are all weaker than clear ice of the same thickness. Nobody can tell you ice is safe — not us, not a neighbor, not a report — so treat these as a floor, not a promise, and drill your way out rather than walking out on faith.

Under four inches

Stay off. There is no version of this that is worth it, however good the bite is supposed to be.

Four inches

The common guideline for walking out on new clear ice, one person at a time, spread out, with a spud bar going ahead of you.

Five to seven

Where people start thinking about a snowmobile or an ATV. More ice, more spacing, and still no reason to hurry.

A foot or more

What gets talked about for a small vehicle. We do not drive on the ice and we do not recommend it to guests.

Check the thickness yourself, often. Ice can lose two inches between where you parked and where you want to sit, and the only way to know is to drill.

Local knowledge

Where does the ice stay sketchy the longest?

This is where a chain of lakes is different from a single round lake. The Eagle River Chain is the world’s largest inland chain of freshwater lakes, and all those basins are tied together by channels and thoroughfares that keep moving water all winter. Current eats ice from underneath. A spot can have eight inches of good ice forty yards out and two inches over the channel, with nothing on the surface to tell you.

The usual suspects, anywhere on the chain: the narrows between lakes, river inlets and outlets, spring holes, pressure cracks and ridges, anywhere a bubbler or aerator is running near a dock, and any patch of snow-covered slush that insulated the ice instead of adding to it. Early in the year we also stay well off the dark spots and the gray, matte-looking ice and keep to the clear stuff.

Gear

What do you carry on early ice?

Not much, and all of it cheap. A spud bar to tap ahead of every step, ice picks worn on your chest where you can actually reach them, forty feet of rope in the sled, cleats, and a float suit or at minimum a life jacket under your shell. Pull your gear in a sled rather than carrying it so your hands are free and your weight stays spread out.

Then the part that costs nothing: go with somebody, stay spread apart, and tell a third person where on the lake you will be and when you will be back. If you are new to the chain and would rather learn it from someone who fishes it every winter, our notes on hiring a guide on the chain and our fishing page are the place to start. When there is enough ice to settle in, the ice fishing guide picks up where this one leaves off.

Where to stay for first ice

Both cabins are open all winter and both sit on the water, which is the whole point in December — The O.G. on Lake Arbutus and The Grandy Dandy on the Sugar Camp Chain, each with a hot tub for afterward and room to spread wet gear out to dry. Early-ice weekends are quiet, which is exactly why we like them.

Book The O.G. →Book The Grandy Dandy →

Good to know

Common questions

How thick should the ice be before you walk on it?
The guideline anglers around here go by is at least four inches of new, clear, solid ice for walking, with more for anything heavier. White or honeycombed ice is weaker than clear ice, so thickness alone is not the whole story. No ice is ever completely safe, and conditions change day to day, so check with a local bait shop or resort before you head out and drill as you go.
When is first ice usually safe on the Eagle River Chain?
It varies every year. Shallow bays and narrows lock up first, usually weeks before the big wind-swept basins, so there is often fishable ice on one spot while another part of the chain is still open water. Treat each lake and each bay as its own question rather than assuming the whole chain froze at once.
Why is ice on a chain of lakes less predictable?
Because water moves between the lakes. The channels and thoroughfares that connect the Eagle River Chain and the Sugar Camp Chain carry current all winter, and current keeps ice thin long after the surrounding lake looks solid. Springs, inlets, outlets and aerators do the same thing on a smaller scale.